History: Amherst College vs Vanderbilt University

Side-by-side ROI comparison · Bachelor's Degree
Return on Investment
10-year earnings ÷ tuition · higher is better
Amherst College
Amherst, MA
Vanderbilt University
Nashville, TN
4.9x
$269,120 tuition
2.9x
$255,784 tuition
$1,325,630 10-yr earnings · Private nonprofit
$745,351 10-yr earnings · Private nonprofit

Head-to-Head

Amherst College Vanderbilt University
Earnings Multiple 4.9x 2.9x
4-Year Tuition $269,120 $255,784
Year 1 Earnings $56,444 $46,856
10-Year Earnings $1,326K $745K
DegreeWorth Score 52/100 45/100
Acceptance Rate 9.8% 6.3%

Both programs have high AI automation risk (44% task exposure) — the same career paths apply to History graduates regardless of school. See full AI analysis →

ROI Breakdown

How tuition costs translate into long-term earnings for History graduates.

Amherst College Vanderbilt University
4-Year Tuition (In-State) $269,120 $255,784
10-Year Projected Earnings $1,326K $745K
Earnings Multiple (In-State) 4.9x 2.9x
5-Year Salary Growth +181% +88%

"Earnings Multiple" = projected 10-year earnings ÷ 4-year tuition. Higher is better. Not a discounted financial ROI.

AI Disruption Scenarios

Both schools share identical AI exposure for History (same career paths). The score differences below reflect how each school's earnings and ROI hold up under stress.

Amherst College Vanderbilt University
Optim. Base Pessim. Optim. Base Pessim.
10-Year Earnings $1,415K $1,326K $1,104K $772K $745K $658K
Earnings Multiple 5.3x 4.9x 4.1x 3.0x 2.9x 2.6x
DegreeWorth Score 54 52 47 46 45 40

For the full AI analysis of History career paths, see the Amherst College or Vanderbilt University program pages.

Earnings Trajectory Comparison

Projected annual earnings for History graduates. Year 1 uses actual reported data.

Tuition Gap
$13,336
Vanderbilt University saves you this
Year 1 Earnings Gap
$9,588/yr
Amherst College grads earn more
ROI Range (In-State)
4.9x / 2.9x
Earnings multiple (10yr earnings ÷ tuition)

Career Paths

History graduates from both schools map to the same career paths. Differences in earnings reflect school prestige, location, and employer networks.

Career Path Wage Openings/yr Growth AI Risk
Natural sciences managers $161,180 8,500 +3.7% 50%
Managers, all other $136,550 106,700 +4.5% 47%
History teachers, postsecondary $81,500 1,700 -0.2% 51%
Historians $74,050 300 +2.2% 47%
Secondary school teachers, except special and career/technical education $64,580 66,200 -1.6% 33%
Curators $61,770 1,800 +7.0% 50%
Archivists $61,570 1,100 +3.8% 50%
Museum technicians and conservators $47,460 1,900 +5.4% 24%
Want to compare different schools or majors? Try the freeform comparison tool →

Explore Each Program

More History Comparisons

History Overview

Frequently Asked Questions

Which is better for History: Amherst College or Vanderbilt University?
Amherst College scores 52/100 while Vanderbilt University scores 45/100. Vanderbilt University has significantly lower tuition, which drives its competitive ROI. The best choice depends on whether you prioritize raw earnings or return on investment.
Which school has better ROI for History?
Amherst College has an in-state earnings multiple of 4.9x vs Vanderbilt University's 2.9x. That means Amherst College grads earn more per dollar spent on tuition.
How do Amherst College and Vanderbilt University compare on History earnings?
Year 1 median earnings are $56,444 at Amherst College vs $46,856 at Vanderbilt University. Over 10 years, the projected totals are $1,325,630 vs $745,351 — a difference of $580,279.
How much does History cost at each school?
Four-year in-state tuition is $269,120 at Amherst College and $255,784 at Vanderbilt University. Both programs lead to the same History career paths — the cost difference is the main factor in ROI.
Data: U.S. Department of Education College Scorecard (earnings, debt), Bureau of Labor Statistics 2024-2034 (employment projections), OpenAI GPTs-are-GPTs research (AI task exposure), Felten et al. AIOE. Scenarios use a continuous weighting function combining AI exposure and BLS job growth projections. "Earnings Multiple" is total 10-year projected earnings divided by tuition — not a discounted financial ROI. Last updated 2025.